The main difference between AWS EKS (Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service) and self-managed Kubernetes clusters lies in who is responsible for managing the control plane, infrastructure, and operational aspects of the Kubernetes environment:
-
Managed vs. Self-Managed Control Plane:
- EKS: With AWS EKS, AWS manages the Kubernetes control plane, including the API server, etcd database, scheduler, and controller manager. AWS ensures high availability, scalability, and reliability of the control plane components, relieving users of the operational burden.
- Self-Managed: In self-managed Kubernetes clusters, users are responsible for provisioning, configuring, and managing the Kubernetes control plane components themselves. This includes deploying and maintaining the API server, etcd cluster, and other control plane components.
-
Managed Infrastructure vs. Self-Managed Infrastructure:
- EKS: EKS provides managed infrastructure for running Kubernetes clusters, including managed node groups for worker nodes. AWS handles provisioning, scaling, and managing the underlying EC2 instances, networking, and storage resources.
- Self-Managed: In self-managed Kubernetes clusters, users are responsible for provisioning and managing the infrastructure required to run Kubernetes, including EC2 instances, networking, storage, and security groups. Users have full control over the infrastructure configuration and management.
-
Operational Responsibilities:
- EKS: With EKS, AWS manages operational tasks such as cluster upgrades, patching, backups, and monitoring of the control plane and managed node groups. AWS also provides integration with other AWS services for logging, monitoring, and security.
- Self-Managed: In self-managed Kubernetes clusters, users are responsible for performing operational tasks such as upgrading Kubernetes versions, applying security patches, managing backups, monitoring cluster health, and troubleshooting issues.
-
Integration with AWS Services:
- EKS: EKS integrates seamlessly with other AWS services such as IAM, VPC, CloudWatch, CloudTrail, ELB, EBS, and EFS. Users can leverage AWS features for networking, storage, security, monitoring, and auditing within their Kubernetes clusters.
- Self-Managed: Users of self-managed Kubernetes clusters need to configure and manage integrations with AWS services manually, which may require additional effort and expertise.
Overall, the choice between AWS EKS and self-managed Kubernetes clusters depends on factors such as operational preferences, expertise, resource constraints, and the level of control and management desired by the organization. EKS provides a fully managed platform for running Kubernetes clusters in the AWS cloud, while self-managed clusters offer more flexibility and control but require additional operational effort.
